I guess I'll try my hand to think of what you like
You're interested in me I think you'd be surprised
To find the feeling's mutual but I've disguised
To tell you I've waited a million silent nights
I pull your name out of the hat and my heart drops
A fifteen-dollar limit, do I get him socks?
Or candy but I like to think outside the box
On the 25th at 12, that's when you hear me knock
Tell me what you're wanting this year
Underneath the tree it might appear
Thinking we skip the banter
I'll be your secret Santa
Tell me what you're wanting this time
It might slip into your stocking tonight
Don't need Rudolf or Prancer
I'll be your secret Santa
Were you happy with the gift?
Were you surprised by the gift?
Were you thinking what a gift this is?
I ain't tryna freak you out
But I'm sitting on your couch and
I'm trying not to lose my (fa la, la, la, la)
Wish I avoided altogether
I should've wrote a letter
Can you just tell me what you think?
You say you waited for forever
Then you give me your sweater
And seal it with a kiss like
I pulled your name out of the hat and my heart dropped
A fifteen dollar limit doesn't get a whole lot
Maybe candy, but that lacks a certain je ne sais quoi
Thanks for letting me in and Merry Christmas my love
Tell me what you're wanting this year
Underneath the tree it might appear
Thinking we skip the banter
I'll be your secret Santa
Tell me what you're wanting this time
It might slip into your stocking tonight
Don't need Rudolf or Prancer
I'll be your secret Santa
I lock eyes on a present with a bow that's pink
A plethora of every one of my favorite things
Say you also pulled my name by coincidence
And that's when we realize we've been set up by friends
Tell me what you're wanting this year (this year)
Underneath the tree it might appear (might appear)
Thinking we skip the banter (we skip the banter)
I'll be your secret Santa (I'll be your secret Santa boyy)
Tell me what you're wanting for time (this time)
It might slip into your stocking tonight (tonight)
Don't need Rudolf or Prancer
I'll be your secret Santa
Ah, ah (fa la, la, la, la, la, la, la, la)
Surprise